Asbestos ‘€“ the “killing stone”

Marela, the killing stone, asbestos’€¦it goes by many names’€¦thousands of people who once mined the fatal mineral have been shunned by the mining sector and are now made to wait in vain for government compensation while fatal diseases linked to asbestos rage through their community.

Professor Tony Davies, former director of the National Centre for Occupational Health has been trying to turn the tide since 1991 and pump some much needed money, in the form of compensation, into the destitute mining communities in the Northern Province.

Davies with the assistance of community volunteers and occupation health nurses employed by the health department, are carrying out thousand of examinations in the community every year and assisting former asbestos miners to apply for compensation.

“These people have been exploited for decades by the mining sector,” said Davies.

Now retired, Davies and his wife Deidre, a registered nurse, spend two weeks of every three months, examining patients and assisting the mostly illiterate and destitute residents to apply for compensation. Every two years the couple stay for six months, examining 20 patients daily.

Of the 770 women who were examined by Davies (between April and September of 1996) and who worked on the asbestos mines between 1929 and 1992, a shocking 741 (96,2%) were clinically diagnosed with pleural and/or parenchymal (lung) asbestosis.

Even more damning is that none of these women had been examined since leaving the mines (some more than 50 years ago).

“This is evidence that there is a large, unrecognised burden of asbestos-related lung diseases among women in rural areas of South Africa who have worked on asbestos mines,” Davies said.

Many of these women started working on the asbestos mines when they were as young as six years.

Most of the women worked as cobbers (crushing asbestos ore) while for the rest, the most common task was employment in the mill or plant as sweepers, cleaners, sorters and machine minders.

A small percentage had done domestic work in the mine compound or in the mine house, while a few were employed packing fibre or stitching up the sacks.

This was despite the fact that the underground employment of women and children under 16 years was legally prohibited after 1911. Although hand cobbing of asbestos by women and children was formally prohibited in 1973, the asbestos mines in the Northern Province continued this practice until 1992.

Davies’€™ research found the average length of service among the women to be almost 11 years.

Known as the Pietersburg asbestos field, the mines lay in the southeastern part of the Northern Province, along an arc close to the middle reaches of the Olifantsriver, about 100km long.

“Occupational lung diseases among men and women have been nrecognised and unreported for about 50 years,” said Davies.

Amosite mining began at Penge mine in 1914, and this became the largest mine in the area and the world’€™s main, and since 1976, the only commercial source of amosite.

It employed up to 7 000 men and women when production was at its peak in the 1960s and 1970s, and the labour turnover was at times close to 100 percent per annum.

Almost all the smaller mines closed around 1976, while Penge (and the associated mines at Weltevrede and Kromellenboog) closed in 1992.

What is alarming is that asbestos mining continued in these areas up until nine years ago, while studies as far back as 1931 pointed towards asbestos-related disease.

Of the 754 women whose marital status was known, 410 were widowed and of these 351 had been married to miners. Of these 351, 274 were accepted, after verbal autopsy, as having died of respiratory causes.

Davies pointed out that women were at a disadvantage on several fronts:

  • X-rays are not taken in full inspiration (after a very deep breath). In addition, the breast shadows tended to make the interpretation of the lower zone changes difficult;
  • Labour registers of women were not kept by the majority of mines;
  • Many of the women are illiterate and unable to carry out a task such as signing their names on the application form (fingerprints are being used by Davies);
  • Many women are being misdiagnosed as having a heart disease as inexperienced doctors do not expect asbestosis.

“We are trying to pump as much money into this areas as possible through compensation. This community is carrying a huge load of disability and disease,” Davies said.

“What is clear is that there was no such thing as non-risk work on an asbestos mine.”

The Northern Province health department has trained eight occupational health nurses who are doing benefit examinations across the province. Some doctors are also now starting to do these examinations. ‘€“ Health-e News Service

Asbestos: the facts

Asbestos is a mineral rock from the earth that is resistant to heat and corrosive chemicals.

Mining of asbestos in South Africa started around 1893 in the Northern Cape and subsequently expanded to the Northern Province and Mpumalanga. Mining included all three types of commercial asbestos ‘€“ white asbestos or chrysotile, blue asbestos or crocidolite and brown asbestos or amosite.

In 1977 South Africa was the third biggest asbestos producer in the world, with a peak of 380 000 tons. Most of the mined asbestos was exported.

In South Africa today, asbestos is mainly used for building materials and pipes. These include sheets for roofing, walls and ceilings, gutters, chimney, pipes, sewerage pipes and water pipes. But usage is decreasing rapidly.

The incurable diseases caused by asbestos are asbestosis and cancer.

It can take from 10 to 40 years for a person to develop an asbestos related disease.

Asbestosis is caused when a person breathes in the invisible, very fine asbestos fibres, which are suspended in the air. These lodge mainly in the lower parts of the lungs and cause inflammation. As the inflammation heals, it leaves scar tissue so that the delicate tissues of the lungs begin to lose their elasticity. As this scarring process continues, the lungs lose their ability to deliver enough oxygen to the blood.

In advanced disease the person has difficulty breathing and performing daily tasks. Many patients may experience years of poor quality life and disability. They may die of shortness of breath or heart failure due to the increased strain on the heart.

Asbestos fibres can cause cancer many years after exposure. There are two types of cancer:

  • Cancer in the lung itself. This accounts for 80% of total asbestos-induced cancers. It is hard to diagnose, it spreads fast and can rarely be cured.
  • Cancer of the lining of the lung or abdomen. This is called mesothelioma and is almost always caused by exposure to asbestos.

People who are exposed to asbestos and smoke as well, greatly increase their chances of developing lung cancer.

Asbestos dumps are scattered all over the mining areas, with up to 82 in the Northern Cape.

Some have only recently been rehabilitated. Asbestos dust from the dumps is blown or washed into nearby villages. In Penge, for example, a dump (recently rehabilitated) is situated adjacent to the hospital.

Rehabilitation of the dumps has already cost the government R44-million, with at least another R52-million need to complete the task.

Author

  • Health-e News

    Health-e News is South Africa's dedicated health news service and home to OurHealth citizen journalism. Follow us on Twitter @HealtheNews

Free to Share

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.


Related

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay in the loop

We love that you love visiting our site. Our content is free, but to continue reading, please register.

Newsletter Subscription