While victory is certain for Jacob Zuma’€™s ANC in the imminent elections, the composition of his new Cabinet is far less certain. For Zuma owes his ascendancy to a number of different groups, and they will be expecting rewards.

But when allocating Cabinet posts, Zuma and his team should not forget that they also owe ordinary citizens ministers that can drive and implement service delivery.

In the past six months, new health minister Barbara Hogan has proven she has the ability to lead the overhaul of health and to work with a variety of players to achieve this.

Our health system is sick, something the ANC acknowledged at Polokwane last December. Yet for years under former health minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang, malpractices were permitted to continue ad nauseum because the minister was an Mbeki loyalist.

HIV/AIDS is by far the country’€™s biggest cause of death, yet its treatment and care was subverted and stalled by Tshabalala-Msimang, resulting in an estimated 330 000 unnecessary deaths and the needless infection of some 30 000 babies a year with HIV.

Infant mortality is worse now than it was under apartheid. South Africa is one of only 12 countries in the world where the proportion of children dying has increased in the 1990s and 2000s.

Some 20 000 babies are still-born in South Africa every year and another 22 000 die before one month of age, according to a report released last year called ‘€œEvery death counts‘€.

At least 1 600 mothers die from complications of pregnancy or childbirth each year, but over half the deaths of mothers giving birth in clinics could have been avoided if patients had been monitored properly. Many of the stillbirths could also have been saved if their mothers’€™ pregnancies had been properly monitored, according to the report.

Patients wait for treatment at health facilities for hours, often with fatal consequences. Poor infection control in hospitals means that patients pick up other sicknesses, particularly those with poor immune systems such as babies, the elderly and people with HIV/ AIDS.

Clinics are poorly resourced, and the referral system from clinics to district and regional hospitals is dysfunctional in many parts of the country. This means people needing care get caught in the cracks and literally die in transit to proper care.

There are massive vacancies in the public sector health institutions. Nurses and doctors are overworked and under-paid and their working environment is conducive to making mistakes. Yet when they make mistakes, they and their managers are seldom held accountable.

Within the health department itself, the vacancy rate is substantial. Qualified audits are the norm as is massive over-spending by provinces. This financial year, for example, KwaZulu-Natal’€™s health department starts with a deficit of over R1-billion largely as a result of under-budgeting for HIV/AIDS.

In a desperate attempt to deal with over-expenditure, the Free State, adopted the opposite response to KZN and simply suspended its HIV/AIDS treatment programme last November ‘€“ at a cost of an estimated 30 lives a day.

One small Barbara Hogan is not going to solve all problems. But she has experience in financial management and is a systems person. Rising at 4am every day and working late into the night, in the six months since her appointment she is beginning to bring a semblance of order to the shambles.

In addition, she has shown herself to be someone able to listen to, and consider, other people’€™s points of view, rather than being a slave to ideology.

For example, her predecessor saw the private health sector as the enemy and there are many in the ANC, Cosatu and the SA Communist Party who believe that the National Health Insurance system ‘€“ a key ANC election promise to be phased in over the next five years ‘€“ should mean the end of private health.

So far, Hogan has been pragmatic is her approach, saying that it makes no sense to undermine the private sector when the public sector is performing so poorly.

In many health areas, there are no yardsticks against which health facilities are measured. To rectify this, last Friday (17 April), Hogan set up a Ministerial Advisory Committee for Quality, Safety and Standards .

Three sub-committees — on standards, norms and guidelines;  infection prevention and control and patient safety and quality improvement ‘€“ will drive the committee.   This will go a long way to providing a framework against which health facilities can be measured, as well as a plan for how patients’€™ needs can be protected.

Hogan’€™s biggest challenge is to get provincial health departments ‘€“ the implementers of policy ‘€“ to work with her. She herself has acknowledged that the country effectively has nine different health systems, as conditions between each province differ so greatly.

This too needs the ANC government’€™s urgent attention as making the provinces the sole implementers of health and education has clearly failed.


  • Health-e News

    Health-e News is South Africa's dedicated health news service and home to OurHealth citizen journalism. Follow us on Twitter @HealtheNews