Cutting the cost to conceive
For couples who can’t conceive naturally, in vitro fertilisation (IVF) can cost ten of thousands of rands but that may be changing.
Cecilia Biyela* is a 31-year old mom from Nyanga, Cape Town, who struggled for eight years to fall pregnant.
Apart from her painful longing for a child of her own and feelings of inadequacy for not being able to conceive, Cecilia’s infertility also strained her marriage: “It was bad. We used to fight every day,” she admits.
Her self-esteem plummeted as she faced scornful labels such as “idlolo” (barren) and “stjoekoe” (failure).
After almost eight frustrating and tension-filled years, Cecilia and her husband Victor* opted for IVF – a medical procedure in which a woman’s egg and a man’s sperm are combined in a laboratory and then planted back into the woman’s womb to increase her chance of pregnancy.
On their second try, she became pregnant and just over a year ago their son was born.
“I couldn’t be happier,” Cecilia tells Health-e News. “He is everything to me.”
While she says her marriage has improved since the birth of their son, she still fears judgment from her community about her infertility and does not want people to know that she did not conceive naturally.
Infertility takes a mental toll
The inability to conceive could have a serious impact on the psychological well-being and social status of women, according to University of Cape Town professor Silke Dyer, who studied the emotional and social experiences of women and men visiting an infertility clinic in Cape Town.
In the study, women reported being sworn at and physically abused by partners while in-laws shunned them. Most women interviewed by Dyer felt desperate, intensely lonely – and even suicidal. Men reported feelings of sadness, isolation and inadequacy.
Dr Jack Biko, a gynaecologist at the Netcare Femina Hospital in Pretoria says that infertility often results in extramarital affairs, polygamy and even divorce.
“Patients often feel pressurised, guilt, shame, diminished self-esteem, indulge in self blame, and then isolate themselves or over-compensate,” Biko tells Health-e News. “The family often adds more pressure, and humiliates and discriminates against these couples.”
Infertility in developing countries is on the rise and almost double that of affluent countries. According to the World Health Organisation, the most common cause of infertility in Africa are untreated sexually transmitted infections (STI) and complications from past pregnancies.
Untreated STIs like gonorrhea and chlamydia can damage a woman’s fallopian tubes, making it difficult for the man’s sperm to reach her ovaries. Other infections that spread to the pelvic area, like tuberculosis, can also result in infertility.
A bundle of joy comes with hefty cost
But couples interested in IVF, which is not covered by medical aids, are often met by a hefty price tag few can afford.[quote float=”right”]“The family often adds more pressure, and humiliates and discriminates against these couples”
At a private clinic, you can expect to pay between R25 000 and R35 000 for one IVF treatment, and although there are some treatment options offered at state facilities, most will still charge tens of thousands of rands for treatment.
But there is another option for couples on a budget.
Dr Thabo Matsaseng used to have a successful private KwaZulu-Natal gynaecological practice but he became frustrated that he couldn’t assist patients with infertility.
“In my practice, I saw many women struggling to conceive, “ says Matsaseng. “I witnessed their battles and desperation, and it frustrated me that I couldn’t do anything except to refer them with a hope that they will get necessary assistance.”
He knew many of them would not be able to afford IVF, so in 2008 he left his private practice and went back to university to specialise in infertility to figure out a way to help these couples.
Today, Matseseng is the head of the Reproductive Medicine Unit at Stellenbosch University’s Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences. He has developed a novel model through which he and his team are able to offer IVF services at around R6 000 at Tygerberg Hospital’s fertility unit.
“It appears as a paradox that in a developing country, where there are so many children without parents, that you want to offer cheap IVF,” Matsaseng tells Health-e News. “But the impact of infertility among this group of women can be catastrophic, and it is paramount to establish at least some sort of system that is not too expensive so that people are able to access treatment and to try and minimize the stigma around infertility.”
Cheaper method has at least 25 percent success rate
He started by taking a critical look at the process of IVF treatment to see where they could reduce costs. First they cut down on human resources and took more responsibility to save money that would have gone towards staff salaries.
Instead of having an IVF co-ordinator to book and confirm appointments, they communicate with patients using SMS. Through a public-private interaction with the Aevitas Clinic in Pinelands in Cape Town, they save on the price of consumables and certain laboratory services.
]He also made some changes to the treatment process. Generally a patient would receive a large amount of hormone therapy to produce as many eggs as possible, but in Matsaseng’s model lower doses of hormone therapy are use. The lower doses cut costs but still produce a sufficient number of eggs.
When harvesting the eggs, he uses local anaesthesia and conscious sedation instead of placing the patient under anaesthesia that requires theatre time and an anaesthetist.
At almost a quarter of the price of private IVF, Tygerberg Hospital’s fertility unit’s success rate is between 25 to 30 percent in comparison to the 35 to 40 percent achieved by their private colleagues.
The low-cost IVF programme at Tygerberg Hospital has been running for more than four years, and they service around 100 to 120 patients per annum.
But even at that low cost it is still not accessible to everyone, and Matsaseng is continuing to find ways to save costs and perfect an IVF business model that can be rolled out to underserved communities in the country. – Health-e News.
*Name changed upon request
An edited version of this article was published in The Star newspaper.