Window on the world of family medicine
Smoking, domestic violence, HIV, heart attacks, depression… All societies’ woes – many exacerbated by the stresses of globalisation – land up in the hands of doctors.But being a family doctor is often an isolating experience. Thus, the 16th World Congress of Family Doctors (WONCA) held last week in Durban was an opportunity for doctors to get out of their consulting rooms and in touch with new research and new ideas for treating patients. In many ways, the congress ‘ which attracted 2 288 delegates from 76 countries – was an assessment of the pulse rate of the world’s citizens.
US Surgeon General Dr David Blatcher said depression was likely to become the “leading cause of disability in the world in 50 years’ time”, and that suicide was one of the top 10 causes of death in the US. However, doctors tend to “forget to ask patients about depression”, said Satcher.
Tobacco-related illnesses killed four million people in 1999, said WONCA president Dr Michael Boland. In 20 years’ time, there would be 10 million deaths caused by smoking, mostly in the developing world.
But HIV/AIDS is the biggest challenge facing the medical profession, said Boland, and it would kill more people than both world wars had.
Sometimes the concerns of the developed nations seemed very far removed from those of ordinary South Africans ‘ who at best see a clinic nurse once in a while, and certainly don’t have access to a family doctor who remembers the details of their ailments.
US-based Prof Rich Roberts’s prediction that soon “all people” would have access to the same medical knowledge as their doctor via the Internet, seemed absurd for Africans.
In addition, the developed nations’ challenge of assisting an ever-ageing population (thanks to improved medical technology)only served to remind us that Africa’s life expectancy is plummeting because of AIDS.
But at other times, doctors from developed nations raised issues that get scant attention in this country.
“How do you know,” asked Professor Ingid Eckerman from Sweden , ” if the child coughing in your consulting rooms who seems to have a bronchial infection is not suffering from pesticide intoxication? How much do doctors know about persistent organic pollutants?”
A very relevant question, given that in the malaria-plagued parts of South Africa, households are being sprayed with the pesticide, DDT.
Lead poisoning was another issue that gets little attention in South Africa. Toronto-based Dr Alan Abelsohn said a relatively small amount of lead in a child ‘ 10 micrograms per 20 decilitres of blood – can actually cause a decrease of two percentage points of in a child’s IQ, leading to a doubling of mentally disabled children. Leaded petrol ‘ the major source of lead in the environment ‘ is widely used in South Africa.
Doctors were also challenged to pay attention to gender in their practices. Norway’s Professor Kirsti Malterud revealed that women had half the chance of men of getting a kidney transplant in her country, and double the chance of invasive surgery rather than therapeutic assistance to deal with heart problems. In addition, the complaints of women patients were often taken less seriously than those of men.
Interestingly, patients surveyed by Malterud generally felt that they had better service from women doctors, saying that they listened better and male doctors “interrupted more”.
She challenged doctors to empower their women patients by encouraging them to speak about their “strong sides” ‘ the things they did to cope with pain and sickness.
“Doctors know more about what makes people ill than what makes them well,” said Malterud, revealing that women often faced illness and pain with remarkable ‘ but unacknowledged ‘ fortitude.
By recognising and supporting such strength, doctors could empower their patients and offer them a “safe space” to talk about problems such as domestic violence.
An injection of reality came from the rural doctors within WONCA ‘ essentially representing the world’s poorest patients.
“Rural children world-wide are under-weight and under-height,” said Australia’s Professor Roger Strasser. “Economic downturns have more of an effect on rural communities, who suffer significant stress when there is a downturn. But there is a lack of counselling and mental health facilities in rural areas.”
South Africa’s Dr Steve Reid was even more explicit: “In South Africa, ‘rural’ means poor’¦ but the Department of Health has adopted a piecemeal programme to address gaps in rural health delivery.”
This programme consisted of “importing 500 Cuban doctors, compulsory conscription of newly qualified doctors and a token rural allowance”.
He said government should instead concentrate on training people from rural areas to become healthcare providers.
WONCA has committed itself to action to eradicate tobacco use, and has offered its support for the United Nations campaign to get universal access to affordable anti-retroviral drugs.
World Congress of Family Doctors in Brief
- Four million people died in 1999 of tobacco-related illnesses. In the next 20 years, this figure will rise to 10million ‘ 70% of which will be in the developing world. There are about a billion smokers in the world, and in 2030 smoking will be “the leading cause of preventable death in the world”. ‘ WONCA president Dr Michael Boland.
- Milk products are a major trigger of asthma attacks in children, according to preliminary research conducted in South Africa. Meanwhile, a Norwegian asthma clinic which offered patients complete medical and emotional care from a range of support staff ‘ rather than rushed medical care from a single doctor ‘ found that hospitalisation, sick leave and medication use was reduced. This indicates patients responded better when their emotional needs were addressed.
- The use of antibiotics to treat ear infections in children under the age of two managed to shorten the duration of their infection by only one day, according to a Dutch study. This has resulted in Dutch health authorities recommending to doctors that they wait three days ‘ rather than the usual two ‘ before prescribing amoxillin. There is world-wide concern that the over-prescription of antibiotics will lead to people developing resistance to antibiotics.
- One in five women in the US have been forced to have sex in their lifetimes, while 30% of young women surveyed in Cape Town said that their first sexual experience was forced. Meanwhile, in Uganda 62% of women said they would deal with a problem in their relationship by discussing it with their partner and crying about it, whereas 54% of men would resort to physical violence. For these, and many other reasons, gender was a “key vulnerability factor” influencing HIV prevention and treatment, according to Professor Helen Rees, Director of Wits University’s Reproductive Health Research Unit.